Cards AI

New Jersey Card Shops

Card shops in New Jersey with a storefront you can walk into

34 shops · 3 regions

North Jersey

Central Jersey

South Jersey

The New Jersey shop scene

Card shops across New Jersey with a storefront you can walk into, grouped by region. Each listing says what the shop carries and whether it buys collections, takes grading submissions or runs trade and play nights, based on what the shop publishes itself.

New Jersey's card shops split roughly into two kinds. Sports-first shops like America's Pastime in Fair Lawn, National Card Sharks in Boonton and The Card Capital in Collingswood lead with sports cards. Game stores like The Gathering House in Edison and Phenomenal Games in Lindenwold lead with Pokémon, Magic, Yu-Gi-Oh!, One Piece and Lorcana, and fill their calendars with play nights. Plenty of shops do both.

If you're selling, start with the shops that say they buy. Close to half of the shops listed here say they buy cards or collections, and about a quarter take grading submissions, which saves shipping your own order to PSA or BGS. The FAQ below names them.

Two small chains cover a lot of the map. Monmouth Sports Cards has eight New Jersey stores, from Midland Park and Livingston down to Marlton, Deptford and Mays Landing, and Epic Trading Collectibles has stores in Springfield, Woodbridge Center and the Ocean County Mall. For weeknight play, Big Pack in Rochelle Park runs Pokémon nights on Wednesdays and Fridays, and Card Shop Near Me in Princeton Junction runs Magic Wednesday through Friday.

Questions

How many card shops are in this New Jersey directory?
34 shops with 43 storefronts are listed. Each has a street address; shops with a full profile link to their own page.
Which New Jersey card shops buy collections?
These shops say they buy cards or collections: America's Pastime (Fair Lawn), Bergen County Sports Cards (Bergenfield), Big Pack Hobby Shop (Rochelle Park), Card Shop Near Me (Princeton Junction), East Coast Connection (Lyndhurst), Epic Trading Collectibles (Springfield), Evan's Sports Cards and Collectibles (Voorhees), IHC Cards & Collectibles (Hamilton Township), Kaleido TCG (Jersey City) and National Card Sharks (Boonton).
Where can I drop off cards for grading?
Shops that list grading submissions (PSA, BGS, CGC or SGC): Bergen County Sports Cards (Bergenfield), Boxed Vinyl (Flemington), Frank's Card Shop (Sicklerville), Kaleido TCG (Jersey City), Monmouth Sports Cards (West Long Branch), National Card Sharks (Boonton), The Card Capital (Collingswood) and Wax, Packs, & Throwbacks (Linwood).
Do any shops hold trade nights?
Yes: All In One Collectibles (Wednesday & Friday Nights, Magic Commander), Big Pack Hobby Shop (Wednesdays & Fridays, 6 PM), Card Shop Near Me (Wednesday Night Magic, Thursday Night Magic, Friday Night Magic), IHC Cards & Collectibles (Weekly tournaments held for various TCGs), Phenomenal Games (Monday: Lorcana; Wednesday: Yugioh; Thursday: MTG, Pokemon; Friday: Yugioh; Saturday: Yugioh, Lorcana; Sunday: Yugioh, Pokemon, One Piece), Royal Cardz (Monthly Trade Nights), The Card Capital (first Saturday of every month) and The Gathering House (Commander Night every night except set release events).

Related