America's Pastime

Fair Lawn, NJ

25-05A Broadway, Fair Lawn, NJ 07410

Open today 11:30am–6:00pm

Sports
Vintage
Graded
Sealed
Supplies

America's Pastime on Broadway in Fair Lawn is a sports card shop with vintage, graded cards, sealed wax and supplies. The shop says it buys cards and collections.

Hours: Monday – Friday: 11:30 AM – 6:00 PM, Saturday: 11:30 AM – 4:00 PM, Sunday: Closed
Buys collections: Yes

Card shows near Fair Lawn

Tue3Nov
Garden State Trading Card Show
Every Tue · 3 PM to 9 PM · Baymont by Wyndham
Next: Tue Nov 3
Tue3Nov
Sports Cards and Collectible Show
All In One Collectibles · Randolph · 1 PM to 6 PM
- Sports
- Free
Directions
Wed4Nov
Tri Cities Card Show
Full Auto Arena · Pearl River · 6 PM to 10 PM · 10.4 mi
- Free

All New Jersey card shows

Card shops near Fair Lawn

The closest within 25 miles first.

Big Pack Hobby Shop
Rochelle Park · 1.8 mi
Pokémon · Vintage · Graded · Sealed
Directions Call
Monmouth Sports Cards
Midland Park · +7 more locations · 4.5 mi
Sports · Pokémon · Lorcana · Magic · Sealed
Directions Call
The Baseball Card Store
Midland Park · 5.1 mi
Sports · Pokémon · Magic · Vintage
Directions Call
Bergen County Sports Cards
Bergenfield · 5.8 mi
Sports · Pokémon
Directions Call
Trace 'n Chase
Totowa · 6.2 mi
Sports · Pokémon · Sealed
Directions Call
The Game Zone
Hillsdale · 6.6 mi
Pokémon · Yu-Gi-Oh! · Magic
Directions Call

All New Jersey card shops

Details last checked Tuesday, September 15, 2026.