Cards AI

Wisconsin Card Shops

Card shops in Wisconsin with a storefront you can walk into · Updated Nov 2

41 shops · 6 regions

Milwaukee Metro

Madison & South Central

Southeast Wisconsin

Fox Valley & Green Bay

Western Wisconsin

Central & Northern Wisconsin

More shops

Open on Google Maps; we haven't confirmed details.

What to know about Wisconsin card shops

Card shops across Wisconsin with a storefront you can walk into, from Milwaukee, Waukesha County and Madison to Green Bay, the Fox Valley, Eau Claire, La Crosse and Wausau. Each listing says what the shop carries, based on what the shop publishes itself.

Greater Milwaukee has the most shops. There are sports card stores in Brown Deer, Brookfield, Pewaukee and West Allis, TCG stores in Glendale, Greenfield, St. Francis and South Milwaukee, and Oconomowoc has three card shops of its own. Kenosha has Pokémon and TCG stores, and Racine, Caledonia and Twin Lakes add more to the south.

Madison has sports card and TCG shops on both sides of town, and Stoughton, Janesville and Beloit each have a card shop. In the Fox Valley and Green Bay, Appleton, Kaukauna, Oshkosh and Green Bay have sports card and Pokémon stores.

Coulee Cards & Gaming has stores in Onalaska, Eau Claire and Wausau, and Eau Claire, Menomonie and Hudson have card shops as well. Up north, Stevens Point, Schofield, Birnamwood and Woodruff have sports card shops, several with vintage cards.

Hours vary from shop to shop, and some open only a few days a week, so call ahead before you drive. Bring the cards you want to sell or trade, and scan them with Cards AI first so you know recent sold prices and a projected grade before you negotiate.

Questions

How many card shops are in this Wisconsin directory?
41 shops with 43 storefronts are listed. Each has a street address; shops with a full profile link to their own page.
Which Wisconsin card shops buy collections?
These shops say they buy cards or collections: BB Sports Cards (Appleton), Beckett Castle TCG (Caledonia), Black Gold Sports Cards (Pewaukee), BMW Sportscards (Madison), Card God Shop (South Milwaukee), Cardboard Legacy (Oshkosh), Coulee Cards & Gaming (Onalaska), Evolution Gaming (Butler), Goldenrod City Collectibles (Twin Lakes) and Iconic Sports Cards (Hudson).
Where can I drop off cards for grading?
Shops that list grading submissions (PSA, BGS, CGC or SGC): 5 Star Cards (Oconomowoc), Black Gold Sports Cards (Pewaukee), Card God Shop (South Milwaukee), Cardboard Legacy (Oshkosh), Coulee Cards & Gaming (Onalaska), Iconic Sports Cards (Hudson) and Lake Country Cards (Oconomowoc).
Do any shops hold trade nights?
Yes: Card God Shop (Monday: Dragon Ball Fusion World 6 PM, Tuesday: Pokémon 6 PM, Wednesday: Digimon/Union Arena 5 PM/Riftbound 6 PM, Thursday: One Piece 6 PM, Friday: Fusion World/Gundam 6 PM, Saturday: Pokémon/Fusion World noon/Gundam 6 PM, Sunday: Masters noon/One Piece 2 PM), HoneyBee Games (Riftbound Weds 6pm; MTG draft Fri 6PM; MTG stnd Sat 12PM; OP SUN 1pm; pokemon sun 4pm), Lake Country Cards (Friday nights), Marblehead's Games (Friday nights, Lorcana), Misty Mountain Games (Friday Night Magic, commander), My Animix (Friday nights, Yu-Gi-Oh!) and Pegasus Games (Trans Gaming Night on Tuesday the 7th).

Related