Cards AI

Indiana Card Shops

Card shops in Indiana with a storefront you can walk into · Updated Oct 31

35 shops · 6 regions

Indianapolis Metro

Northwest Indiana

Michiana

Fort Wayne & Northeast Indiana

West Central Indiana

Southern Indiana

More shops

Open on Google Maps; we haven't confirmed details.

What to know about Indiana card shops

Card shops across Indiana with a storefront you can walk into, from Indianapolis, Noblesville and Plainfield to Fort Wayne, South Bend, Valparaiso, Lafayette, Bloomington and Evansville. Each listing says what the shop carries, based on what the shop publishes itself.

The Indianapolis area has the most shops. The city has sports card stores on the north side and in Speedway and TCG stores downtown and along Shelby Street, and the suburbs add more in Avon, Brownsburg, Greenwood, New Whiteland, Greenfield and Lebanon. Moonshot Games has stores in Noblesville and Plainfield, and Noblesville has sports card and graded card shops as well.

Northwest Indiana has sports card shops in Dyer, Hobart and Valparaiso, a Pokémon and TCG store in Crown Point, and shops in Lowell and Knox. In Michiana, Granger has a sports card shop, and Goshen and Warsaw each have a card and game store. Fort Wayne has a Pokémon shop and more card stores around the city.

Tier 1 Games has stores in Lafayette and Kokomo, and Bloomington has TCG stores on both sides of town. In southern Indiana, Evansville has sports card and TCG shops, Columbus has a game center with Pokémon and Yu-Gi-Oh!, and Batesville and Scottsburg each have a sports card shop.

Northwest Indiana and the Evansville area keep Central time, an hour behind Indianapolis, so check a shop's hours in its own time zone and call ahead before you drive. Bring the cards you want to sell or trade, and scan them with Cards AI first so you know recent sold prices and a projected grade before you negotiate.

Questions

How many card shops are in this Indiana directory?
35 shops with 37 storefronts are listed. Each has a street address; shops with a full profile link to their own page.
Which Indiana card shops buy collections?
These shops say they buy cards or collections: Abrams Sports Cards and Collectibles (Knox), Cards and Castles Tabletop Shop (New Whiteland), Clever Bay Sports & Gaming (Evansville), Indy Card Exchange (Indianapolis), K & L Cards (Greenwood), K0s Card Shop (Avon), Moonshot Games (Noblesville), More Fun Sportscards Store (Dyer), Paradigm Games (Indianapolis) and Sports Kings (Scottsburg).
Where can I drop off cards for grading?
Shops that list grading submissions (PSA, BGS, CGC or SGC): Indy Card Exchange (Indianapolis) and Uptown Sports Cards (Batesville).
Do any shops hold trade nights?
Yes: Abrams Sports Cards and Collectibles (Card night, November 5th, 2026), Bulldog Community Gaming (Tuesday Night Magic Commander, Pokemon TCG Weekly Open Play, Yu-Gi-Oh! TCG Weekly Event, MTG Magic 'til Midnight, MTG Standard Showdown, One Piece Casual Play), By The Board Games & Entertainment (weekly special events), Cards and Castles Tabletop Shop (Family Game Night: Wednesdays 4pm-8pm and Sundays 1pm-5pm; Warhammer: Fridays 6pm-10pm; MTG: Tuesdays 12pm-8pm; Pokemon: Sundays 1pm-3pm; Dungeons & Dragons: Saturdays 5pm-10pm), Clever Bay Sports & Gaming (Trade Nights), Common Room Games (MTG Standard Sundays 5pm, MTG Pre-Modern Mondays 6:30pm, MTG Commander Mondays & Thursdays, Warhammer Paint & Play Tuesdays 6pm, MTG Modern Wednesdays 6:30pm, Flesh & Blood Wednesdays 6:30pm, Friday Night Magic 6:30pm, Star Wars Unlimited Sundays 12:30pm, Yu-Gi-Oh Sundays 3pm), Fan Cave Indy (Midnight Madness event includes Trade Night) and Friendly City Games (Magic The Gathering Every Sunday at 5pm, Pokemon two Saturdays per month).

Related