Collectr vs HoloDex comes down to what you want the app to do after the scan. Collectr is the stronger collection tracker: portfolios, raw, graded and sealed filters, Japanese and Chinese edition filters, a huge user base, and an export option on its paid plan. HoloDex is the stronger condition tool: it adds AI observations on centering, whitening and surface wear, plus a Pokédex style set completion experience that many Pokémon collectors love. Neither is built for sports cards, and collectors say neither app's prices are perfect, so check recent sold prices before you buy or sell.
The short answer: pick Collectr if you want to organize and track the value of a big TCG collection over time. Pick HoloDex if you are sorting cards to decide what is worth grading, or you want a fun way to chase set completion.
Here is the full comparison, with prices checked in October 2026.
Collectr vs HoloDex at a glance
Collectr launched in 2022 and is one of the most popular TCG collection apps, with a 4.9 star rating from tens of thousands of App Store reviews. It is built around portfolios. You scan or search a catalog of more than 200,000 products, add cards, graded slabs and sealed product, and track what the collection is worth over time. It is on iPhone and Android.
HoloDex is newer. It launched in September 2025 from a developer called Mavelli and is also on iPhone and Android. It combines camera scanning and market prices with AI condition checks and a collecting experience built around set completion, achievements and wishlists.
Both cover Pokémon, YuGiOh and several other trading card games. If you want deeper looks at each app on its own, we have a full Collectr review and a full HoloDex review.
Scanning and identification
Both apps let you point your camera at a card and get a match with a price. Collectr's scanner matches set, number and variant, then asks you to set the quantity and condition before the card is saved. HoloDex matches the card and pulls its market price.
In practice, both can get the illustration right and the printing wrong. Some HoloDex users report trouble finding exact variants or collector numbers, and Pokémon cards with reverse holo, promo and alternate versions trip up every scanner. Before you save any card, check the collector number and the finish. If you have duplicates, scan them next to each other so a clean copy and a worn copy do not end up as two identical records.
On free scanning, Collectr is more generous. Its free plan includes scanning, pricing and unlimited portfolios, with unlimited scanning on PRO. HoloDex users report that the free tier caps scans at around 30 cards before you need premium, which makes a full binder impossible to enter without paying.
Condition and AI grading
This is HoloDex's main advantage. It runs an AI check that flags visible problems like off center borders, whitening and surface wear. The developer describes the result as an estimate, not a professional grade, and that is the right way to treat it. Collectors use it to decide which cards deserve a closer look before paying to grade them.
Collectr does not grade cards. You set the condition yourself when you add a card, and you can track graded slabs by entering the company and grade from the label. Collectr's recent updates added grade comparisons, which help you see what a card is worth at different grades, but the condition call is yours.
If AI grading is part of your routine, HoloDex has the edge here. Use its observations as a to do list: look at the borders, check the back, and tilt the card under a light. A good inspection session ends with a short list of cards worth submitting and the reasons why.
Collection tracking and organization
This is Collectr's main advantage. It offers unlimited portfolios on the free plan, bulk copy, move and delete between portfolios, and filters for raw cards, graded cards and sealed product. It also has English, Japanese and Chinese edition filters, which matters if you collect Japanese Pokémon. Collectors like it for watching value move day to day and for sharing a portfolio with friends. PRO adds a data export, which is important if you are entering hundreds of cards and want a backup you control.
HoloDex covers the basics well: portfolios, duplicate tracking, wishlists and sync across devices. Its September 2026 update added a Sealed tab, bulk wishlist actions and broader portfolio views with biggest gainers and losers. Its standout is the Pokédex style experience, with set completion tracking and achievements that make filling a binder feel like a game. What it does not document is an export, so check how you would get your data out before you commit a large collection to it.
For a big collection, organize around where cards physically live, like a display binder, a trade box and a sealed shelf, and give each physical copy one home in the app. That keeps the digital total honest.
Prices: where the values come from
Neither app's prices should be treated as gospel, and collectors say so often.
Collectr's values are market estimates. Some users say they can lag or run higher than what cards actually sell for. HoloDex users say its prices come from TCGplayer market data, which is solid for TCG singles but is not the same as eBay sold prices, especially for graded cards.
The consistent advice from collectors on both apps: use the app to track your collection, and check recent eBay sold listings for any card you are about to buy or sell. Asking prices and estimates are not the same as what a card actually sold for.
Pricing: what each app costs
Collectr is free to download, and the free plan covers scanning, pricing data and unlimited portfolios. Collectr PRO costs 7.99 dollars a month or 59.99 dollars a year at the time of writing, and adds unlimited scanning, deeper filters, price history and data export.
HoloDex is free to download with a limited number of free scans. On the US App Store, its plans are listed at 12.99 dollars a month or 49.99 dollars a year, plus a 4.99 dollar weekly option. Unlimited scanning and AI grading are part of the paid tier.
So HoloDex is more expensive month to month and cheaper per year. Pick the billing period around how you actually use it. A one time binder cleanup is a different job from a weekly buying habit.
Which one should you choose?
Choose Collectr if you want to organize a large TCG collection, track raw, graded and sealed product in one place, collect Japanese or Chinese cards, or want to export your data. It is also the easier pick if you want a generous free plan.
Choose HoloDex if you want AI condition checks to sort cards before grading, you enjoy set completion and achievements, or you collect Pokémon and want a Pokédex style experience. Budget for the paid plan, since the free scan limit is low.
Choose neither if you collect sports cards. Both apps are built for trading card games, and neither is a real option for baseball, basketball, football or hockey.
A third option if you also collect sports cards
If your binder mixes Pokémon with sports cards, or you want condition and real sold prices in the same scan, Cards AI covers both. It scans sports cards, Pokémon and YuGiOh, shows recent eBay sold prices for the raw card and for graded copies, and gives a Cards AI Grade for centering, corners, edges and surface (AI estimate only). Saved cards go into a Binder that syncs across your devices. If you are comparing scanners for Pokémon specifically, our guide to the best Pokémon card scanner apps tests them side by side.
And whatever app you use, a local shop is still the fastest way to settle a question about a variant or a card's condition. You can find one near you in our card shop directory.
Frequently asked questions
Is Collectr or HoloDex better for Pokémon? It depends on the job. Collectr is better for organizing and tracking a collection's value, especially with graded and sealed product. HoloDex is better if you want AI condition checks and a set completion experience.
Are Collectr and HoloDex free? Both are free to download. Collectr's free plan includes scanning, pricing and unlimited portfolios. HoloDex's free tier has a low scan limit, and users report about 30 scans before you need a paid plan.
How much does Collectr PRO cost? At the time of writing, 7.99 dollars a month or 59.99 dollars a year.
How much does HoloDex cost? On the US App Store, 12.99 dollars a month or 49.99 dollars a year, with a 4.99 dollar weekly option.
Does HoloDex give a real PSA grade? No. HoloDex gives an AI estimate of visible condition, like centering, whitening and surface wear. It is not an official grade and does not predict exactly what PSA will give the card.
Can I track Japanese Pokémon cards? Collectr has English, Japanese and Chinese edition filters. HoloDex does not publish an exact list of supported card languages, so confirm the set and number of each saved card.
Which app can export my collection? Collectr PRO includes a data export. HoloDex does not document an export, so check how you would move your data before entering a large collection.
Are Collectr and HoloDex prices accurate? They are good for tracking a collection over time, but collectors report that both can differ from actual sales. For any card you plan to buy or sell, check recent eBay sold listings.
Do Collectr or HoloDex work for sports cards? No. Both are built for trading card games. For sports cards, you need an app that covers baseball, basketball, football and hockey.



